Which would you buy?

[Guest jps37033]

I am trying to decide on one of these... Help me pick, I don't know much about any of them. Thanks

FN Herstal FNP40 14 round- $487

Sig 2022 w/night sights 12 round- $469

Beretta px4 storm .40 15 round- $518

Ruger p94 .40 10 round- $399

Taurus 24/7 .40 15 round- $344

I am looking for semi compact enough to CC, reliability (for duration and not ammo picky), good customer service/warranty, and they all have a manual safety which I want.

[TripleDigitRide]

Not the Ruger P Series.

Other than that, go with the one that fits you the best.

Keep us posted.

[Guest eyebedam]

u must be shopping at buds. The PX 4 storm is a nice firearm. What happened to the Walther .40 u bought.

[Guest jps37033]

Nothing. Just got the itch

Looking for one more good piece. Looking at that or a couple of lower priced pieces. I love the look of the XD's, but the no manual safety is what I dont like. Has anyone held a px4 storm? Can you compare it in size to any other handguns?

[Guest bkelm18]

Nothing. Just got the itch

Looking for one more good piece. Looking at that or a couple of lower priced pieces. I love the look of the XD's, but the no manual safety is what I dont like. Has anyone held a px4 storm? Can you compare it in size to any other handguns?

If you want a .45, they make an XD45 that has a manual safety.

[TripleDigitRide]

Nothing. Just got the itch

Looking for one more good piece. Looking at that or a couple of lower priced pieces. I love the look of the XD's, but the no manual safety is what I dont like. Has anyone held a px4 storm? Can you compare it in size to any other handguns?

I know it's not a .40, but they do have an XD45 with an optional manual safety.

[Guest bkelm18]

I know it's not a .40, but they do have an XD45 with an optional manual safety.

Beat ya.

[Guest jps37033]

I will check out the XD with manual safety. Be right back.

[Guest jps37033]

SWEET! Just found one for $475. In the XD kit it comes with, how can the XD holster be worn? waist band, belt, etc;?

[Guest bkelm18]

SWEET! Just found one for $475. In the XD kit it comes with, how can the XD holster be worn? waist band, belt, etc;?

It's worn on the belt. It's pretty cheap but it serves it's purpose.

[Guest jps37033]

I have shot a .45, but its been awhile. How would you compare the recoil of the .40 to the .45?

[TripleDigitRide]

Yea, you'll likely want to go with a different holster. They are cheap. They did slightly improve the design for the XD-M, but still not all that great.

As a matter of fact, if you ask me, all the "extras" that come with the XD are trash. This is coming from a real fan of the XD's.

[Daniel]

I have shot a .45, but its been awhile. How would you compare the recoil of the .40 to the .45?

very similiar imo.

[Guest pjblurton]

I have the FNP40 and I love it. By far the BEST trigger of any polymer framed pistol I have shot. Customer service is awesome!

I was looking for a place to buy a hat with the FN logo, contacted thier marketing department and they got back in touch with me the next day. Asked for my home address and sent me a nice embroidered hat, 3 tee shirts and a handfull of hat pins. FREE!

The Ruger is going to be pretty big to carry. The XD is good if you can live with a striker fired weapon. Don't buy it just for the holster though, it's crap. (Settle down Glock guys, I ain't hate'n, just not my bag)

If you can find an FN to shoot, you owe it to yourself to try it. Very sweet shooter and very accurate. It's my daily carry. If you will be near Memfrica any time soon, PM me, I'll be happy to let you shoot mine.

[Guest superdrew4000]

I just put another 300 rounds through my M&P .45 this afternoon. It has yet to do anything but make me grin like the idiot I am.

[LA_357SIG]

Easy. FNP-45. Way better than the Berretta PX4 I rented. The PX4's muzzle flip is horrible. Shooting them side by side made me appreciate the FNP-45 much better.

[Guest Tom@GunDepot]

XD 45 with thumb safety!!

[Guest bkelm18]

The .40 is a pretty sharp recoil, the .45 is more of push. Hard to describe but I find the recoil of a .45 more pleasant and manageable than a .40.

[Guest jwp]

FN or the Beretta.

[Guest Rugerman]

Like others have said, stay away from the P series, its a good gun, just large. I'd go with the XD, personally.

[Guest tlondon]

I will say the same as some on here. If you are looking for an easily conceaied weapon stay away from the ruger p series. That is not a knock on the gun (I have one and love it) its just BIG and hard to carry hidden

[Guest jpsmith]

The Beretta is a nice gun.

[rd97]

I like the Sig. Mine was extremely accurate and it is very reliable as well.

[Shima]

+1 for the XD45 over anything on your list.

[strob2000]

Beretta