Not looking for a brand war, only a first hand experience discussion....

[Guest Southern Christian Armed]

You must be a benefactor to sell here.

Edited May 29, 2013 by Southern Christian Armed

[jcj]

Well... I've owned XD (45C), XD(m) (3.8 45), and M&P (FS 9mm). I can understand your problem!  

 

I wouldn't be concerned at all about the failure to go into battery on the M&P when riding the slide home. That's really a non-issue and quite common among a variety of guns. They're just not meant to work that way.

 

Personally, I'd keep the M&P for the +2 rounds and night sights if all other factors were equal. Tough choice though since they're both solid firearms with a good track record.

 

Oh, and you're supposed to be a TGO Benefactor before you offer stuff up for sale/trade here. Here's a link for that: http://www.tngunowners.com/forums/store/product/2-premium-membership-6-months/

Not that I'm the forum police or anything, just figured I'd mention it.  Good luck with your decision!

[frankmako]

some time you got to flip a quarter.  

[jdw174]

Haven't owned either, but just from a "handled one in the LGS standpoint" I say keep the M&P.

[scoutfsu]

Why are you riding a slide forward?