Which Sig P238 to purchase?

[True Grit]

I have been looking at the Sig P238 to purchase for pocket summer carry.

The Bi-tone with blackwood grip is 15 oz and the Stainless HD is 20 oz.

The Bi-tone would be more comfortable for EDC in a pocket holster but the HD would have less recoil and nearly indestructible. The price is more for the HD version but is it worth the extra cost and weight?

I would value your opinions.

Sig HD

Products & Services

Sig Bi tone

Products & Services

[Garufa]

In true TGO fashion, I vote for neither.

Not too crazy about two-tone guns. I vote for this...Products & Services

Edited June 9, 2010 by Garufa
spelling

[Loon160T]

In true TGO fashion, I vote for neither.

Not to crazy about two-tone guns. I vote for this...Products & Services

I'm with Garufa on this (it's the one I have).

[eapking]

I'm not normally big on bi-tones either, but in these sizes I find it more appealing. Seems to add something to it.

[Guest cjr]

I have one of each and like the looks of both,I have not shot either.I have a solid black one I have shot and do like.

[jeremy155rr]

I have one of each and like the looks of both,I have not shot either.I have a solid black one I have shot and do like.

3 p238's?

[Guest cjr]

I have the rainbow also

[True Grit]

In true TGO fashion, I vote for neither.

Not too crazy about two-tone guns. I vote for this...Products & Services

So why Nitron over Bi-tone other than the look of a black gun?

[JeffsSig]

All about LOOKs.

Just buy the one you like best.

[Reg]

All about LOOKs.

Just buy the one you like best.

Exactly. Whichever you want to fondle and admire. I like the black Nitron w/ rosewood grips.

[Guest italia]

The HD is about 5 oz. heavier. I'd go for a lighter one and add a magazine or knife to my EDC carry list.

[True Grit]

Thanks guys, I have decided on the HD because if is good looking and feels more substantial in my hand. I'll give a range report as soon as I have a day off and get to the range.

Very good advice from everyone!