Jump to content

Posted Signs and Legal Issues


Guest Glock23ForMe

Recommended Posts

Guest Glock23ForMe

For the record: I have already searched and didn't find anything, although I know there is one, and I was wondering about this.

I have read the TCA about the signs prohibiting firearms in certain establishments. If the sign is not a legal sign, is it still illegal to carry into the establishment provided you have a HCP and are within the rest of the laws.

Also, any loopholes within this rule applying to: Malls, etc.

Link to comment
  • Replies 22
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

For the record: I have already searched and didn't find anything, although I know there is one, and I was wondering about this.

I have read the TCA about the signs prohibiting firearms in certain establishments. If the sign is not a legal sign, is it still illegal to carry into the establishment provided you have a HCP and are within the rest of the laws.

Also, any loopholes within this rule applying to: Malls, etc.

By the time you get your permit, things likely will be clearer than they are at present.

- OS

Link to comment

If it is a properly posted sign then you can't carry there. If it just says no guns allowed, or no concealed carry then you are allowed to carry there, though obviously you won't want to open carry there.

I don't know of any loopholes but someone else might correct me on that one.

Ohshoot will probably chime on on this, he is pretty resourceful when it comes to topics regarding the law.

Link to comment

If it is a properly posted sign then you can't carry there. If it just says no guns allowed, or no concealed carry then you are allowed to carry there, though obviously you won't want to open carry there.

I don't know of any loopholes but someone else might correct me on that one.

Ohshoot will probably chime on on this, he is pretty resourceful when it comes to topics regarding the law.

Link to comment

you can carry anywhere except where alcohol is sold for consumption on site. IF they dont have a correct sign up.

also cant carry in federal buildings, courthouses, or school property.

however, if they ask you to leave, you must leave or you can be charged with trespassing.

and there are some people that believe concealed is concealed...

Link to comment
Guest jackdm3
you can carry anywhere except where alcohol is sold for consumption on site. IF they dont have a correct sign up.

also cant carry in federal buildings, courthouses, or school property.

however, if they ask you to leave, you must leave or you can be charged with trespassing.

and there are some people that believe concealed is concealed...

I heard you could carry in your car to pick up your rugrats, while staying within.

Link to comment
...If it just says no guns allowed, or no concealed carry then you are allowed to carry there, though obviously you won't want to open carry there...

Geez, why not open carry there, if as you say "you are allowed to carry there"?

The fact is that "substantially similar" has never been defined, even by TN Attorney General opinion. Hence, would be up to arresting LEO and consequently, a judge, in each case.

The good news is that we have yet to hear of anyone being charged with carrying past a sign in a business.

The park statute exactly defines the exact wording, and even the minimum size, of a sign, and there has been at least one case of a guy charged with that.

Right now, you can't carry "within the confines of a building open to the public where liquor, wine or other alcoholic beverages that sells liquor for consumption" period, whether posted or not.

There is a bill currently pending which looks likely to pass that will simplify all this by specifying exact sign wording for ALL situations. (although I guess the park statute will stand as is).

- OS

Link to comment
I heard you could carry in your car to pick up your rugrats, while staying within.

correct. I believe though that it was at least highly suggested if not mandatory that you hide it for example in the console or glove box before entering property, and not have it on your person or visible.

not sure on that one as it will be a LONG time before I will personally run into that one.

Link to comment
I'll be sure and tell the judge that you said so, should I get popped.

- OS

did you read the rest of my post??

what else is off limits?

EDIT: maybe I should reword that one,

you can carry anywhere IF they dont have a correct sign up. except where alcohol is sold for consumption on site.

then continue with the rest of the post.

Edited by nightrunner
Link to comment
Guest tennesseevolz

let me pose this question- I drive to knoxville for work, and I cc my 1911, and check into a hotel- the hotel has a full svc bar inside, can i carry? (I think taking it into the hotel is better than leaving it in the parking structure, so i do take it in and leave it loaded during my stay.)

Link to comment
did you read the rest of my post??..

Yes.

Just how "substantially dissimilar" does a sign have to be to make it not binding? You seem to know.

There is no mention of this "trespass" thing everybody touts in the weapons statutes. Criminal trespass is a separate offense entirely, and has nothing to do with whether you are armed or not.

Not to say you might not be charged with it, but you could also be charged with carrying in a posted establishment, too. The owner could just call a cop rather than telling you to leave, eh?

- OS

Link to comment
let me pose this question- I drive to knoxville for work, and I cc my 1911, and check into a hotel- the hotel has a full svc bar inside, can i carry? (I think taking it into the hotel is better than leaving it in the parking structure, so i do take it in and leave it loaded during my stay.)

Bar is generally considered separate establishment for this purpose.

Like a restaurant/bar in a mall, or same in a Bass Pro.

Let's put it this way, no body has ever been charged with it that we know of.

An even grayer area would be actual hotel room with a self service bar, eh?

But that's generally conceded as the room becoming your home for your stay. "Castle" doctrine and all.

- OS

Edited by OhShoot
Link to comment
honestly I always look to see if they quoted TCA law or not. if not, not legal. if so its a legal sign. never seen a legal sign though.

Again, I hope YOUR opinion of an undefined statute term exonerates you if charged.

The statute does not say the TCA law must be quoted.

Any judge could simply deem that the intent of the sign was clear, that it was "substantially similar" enough.

- OS

Edited by OhShoot
Link to comment
Guest 270win

You would not be breaking any law, if the signs does not meet statute requirements, but you can still be asked to leave should someone notice your handgun.

I have not heard of anyone actually going to court over 'proper' or 'improper' signs...i'm guessing b/c either people who are seen with a gun are asked to take the gun to the car and do so...and because most people conceal. It is not like you go through TSA security lines to go to the dept store or grocery store. This is a typical 'feel good' law. You risk max $500 fine over the 'feel good' proper sign statute. I personally don't lose sleep over it...your choice.

Link to comment

But your not supposed to have to search Hi and Low for a sign....there are supposed to be posted in a way that it is "plainly visible"

But as OS said....we have yet to here of person charged with such a violation.

Maybe another reason is because a violation is a misdemeanor. Unless a misdemeanor occurs in an officers presence, there isn't much he can do about it. So it would be up to the property owner to pursue the legal case, assuming you were back outside and even decided to hang around until LE arrived.

I imagine most property owner's just want you and/or your gun out of their place and don't want to take a day off to go to court.

Link to comment
..But as OS said....we have yet to here of person charged with such a violation.

Yah, but I wonder, FG...there are an awful lot towns in TN, so we can't say it has not happened, and maybe more than we think. And there are an awful lot of HCPs revoked each year, and I don't think there's a database of the reasons, is there?

Maybe another reason is because a violation is a misdemeanor. Unless a misdemeanor occurs in an officers presence, there isn't much he can do about it. So it would be up to the property owner to pursue the legal case, assuming you were back outside and even decided to hang around until LE arrived.

I imagine most property owner's just want you and/or your gun out of their place and don't want to take a day off to go to court.

Then again, if an owner spots your gun, all he has to do is call a cop and point you out, then he doesn't have to do anything else. I'd venture to say there are going to be even more owners who feel resentful that they have to post a legal sign to prohibit carry rather than be able to rely on the blanket ban ruling, and might be more prone to do it.

- OS

Link to comment
Yah, but I wonder, FG...there are an awful lot towns in TN, so we can't say it has not happened, and maybe more than we think. And there are an awful lot of HCPs revoked each year, and I don't think there's a database of the reasons, is there?

True, never meant to imply that no one has ever been charged.

There is a database that shows how many HCP are revoked, but I don't think it gives any specific reasons.

Then again, if an owner spots your gun, all he has to do is call a cop and point you out, then he doesn't have to do anything else. I'd venture to say there are going to be even more owners who feel resentful that they have to post a legal sign to prohibit carry rather than be able to rely on the blanket ban ruling, and might be more prone to do it.

- OS

True again, but I still feel the LEO is more apt to tell you to leave than charge, especially if there is any question on if the sign is valid.

Now if HB31255 passes and there is no doubt what a proper sign is and a place post such a proper sign, I doubt I would carry past it.

Edited by Fallguy
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

TRADING POST NOTICE

Before engaging in any transaction of goods or services on TGO, all parties involved must know and follow the local, state and Federal laws regarding those transactions.

TGO makes no claims, guarantees or assurances regarding any such transactions.

THE FINE PRINT

Tennessee Gun Owners (TNGunOwners.com) is the premier Community and Discussion Forum for gun owners, firearm enthusiasts, sportsmen and Second Amendment proponents in the state of Tennessee and surrounding region.

TNGunOwners.com (TGO) is a presentation of Enthusiast Productions. The TGO state flag logo and the TGO tri-hole "icon" logo are trademarks of Tennessee Gun Owners. The TGO logos and all content presented on this site may not be reproduced in any form without express written permission. The opinions expressed on TGO are those of their authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the site's owners or staff.

TNGunOwners.com (TGO) is not a lobbying organization and has no affiliation with any lobbying organizations.  Beware of scammers using the Tennessee Gun Owners name, purporting to be Pro-2A lobbying organizations!

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to the following.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Guidelines
 
We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.