9th Circuit-No Carry Open or Concealed

[AuEagle]

9th Circuit Rules Americans Have No Right to Carry Guns, Either Open or Concealed - Becker News

[hipower]

1 hour ago, AuEagle said:

9th Circuit Rules Americans Have No Right to Carry Guns, Either Open or Concealed - Becker News

The 9th has had quite a record of being ultra lib and anti anything that pertains to civil liberty of conservativism. 

So this isn't surprising. The tale will be to see how other court systems respond to this.

[btq96r]

I'm going to try to set aside some time to read the full opinion, but at a glance, this case involving open carry is one wrinkle that might be unique.

 

[Trekbike]

The US Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit just ruled that THERE IS NO RIGHT TO CARRY – either openly or concealed in public. This ruling impacts RTC laws in AK, HI, CA, AZ, OR, WA, & MT

Can't comment for for all the states listed, but good luck telling the folks in Alaska and Montana they can't carry a firearm...

 

[btq96r]

43 minutes ago, Trekbike said:

The US Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit just ruled that THERE IS NO RIGHT TO CARRY – either openly or concealed in public. This ruling impacts RTC laws in AK, HI, CA, AZ, OR, WA, & MT

Can't comment for for all the states listed, but good luck telling the folks in Alaska and Montana they can't carry a firearm...

 

Incorrect.   This doesn't impact RTC laws in those states.  The ruling validates Hawaii's law, under the premise that the state has the prerogative to restrict carry.  This won't automatically put the law upheld in Hawaii into effect across the 9th Circuit.  It would allow those states to do so, but it's not a court dictated adoption across their jurisdiction as your post would indicate.

[Trekbike]

6 hours ago, btq96r said:

Incorrect.   This doesn't impact RTC laws in those states.  The ruling validates Hawaii's law, under the premise that the state has the prerogative to restrict carry.  This won't automatically put the law upheld in Hawaii into effect across the 9th Circuit.  It would allow those states to do so, but it's not a court dictated adoption across their jurisdiction as your post would indicate.

Well, I guess Mr. Becker's comment that I quoted is misleading IMO.    I will though stand by my comment "good luck with telling folks in Alaska and Montana they can't carry a firearm", maybe just not in connection with this story.