Jump to content

Husband Denied Carry Permit


Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey, I'm new here, so please be kind.

I have my CCW and my husband used to have one as well. He is a medically-retired Army veteran and his permit just expired on December 9th. He applied for a renewal but was denied bec he was sent to a medical institution 4 years ago for being suicidal and was honest about it on his application. What concerns me is, the reason he was suicial is bec the Army doc put him on Lyrica for chronic pain in his shoulders (he's had 3 surgeries) and one of the side effects is suicidal ideations. He told his physiologist that and they sent him straight to the hospital. He was immediately put on a different med for the pain and hasn't had that issue since. On the online application it gives you a place to explain certain answers, which he did, but they still denied him. I feel like they deciding party didn't even bother reading his explanation, but I can't prove it. My questions are 1) Does he ever have a chance of getting his permit back or is he screwed bec of a stupid medication?, 2) Does the medical hospitalization on his record ever "expire", so to speak? For example, after 5 years with no new issues, is it no longer considered a factor?, and 3) Since his permit renewal was denied, will that affect his background check if he tries to buy a new gun? He is a God-fearing man that worked hard to serve his country for 13 years (he only got out bec of injuries incurred while deployed), and has an outstanding military record as an enlisted soldier and then Army Captain. He is devistated. Is there anything we can do?

Posted

Sorry for the difficulties.  Someone who remembers her name will chime in with contact info for a very helpful lady at TDOS who can address this sort of thing. I just can't recall her name at the moment...  

  • Like 1
Posted

I'd get documentation on the medication and side effects from his doctor as well as his military record and try to apply in person rather than online . Get the doctor to write a paper stating that he has no known mental issues and that that the meds caused the problem and that he is no longer taking them and has had no further problems stating how long he has been off them . Might not make any difference but that is what I would try first . Damn shame to be punished for telling the truth .

Eddie

  • Like 2
Posted
  On 12/17/2017 at 10:11 PM, peejman said:

Sorry for the difficulties.  Someone who remembers her name will chime in with contact info for a very helpful lady at TDOS who can address this sort of thing. I just can't recall her name at the moment...  

Expand  

Found this in another thread...thanks  to DaveTN

Program Director, Lisa Knight,P.O. Box 23710 Nashville, TN 37202 (615) 251-8590

  • Like 2
Posted

Thanks to your husband for his service. 

I have no idea whether he will be able to get a permit or not, but Lisa Knight should be able to give you some direction. My guess would be he would have to ask for a hearing. If that happens, as Eddie said, you will need medical documentation.

Good luck.

  • Like 1
Posted

Also, I thought I heard that being "voluntarily admitted" is different than being "forceably admitted" to a mental institution with regard to handgun permits.  I thought a person could only be denied if they were forceably admitted.  If that is truly the case, then maybe what is needed is a clarification of the terms of admittance.  It would be a good question to ask.  Hopefully, Lisa can help you. 

Posted (edited)
  On 12/18/2017 at 11:15 AM, BHG123 said:

Also, I thought I heard that being "voluntarily admitted" is different than being "forceably admitted" to a mental institution with regard to handgun permits.  I thought a person could only be denied if they were forceably admitted.  If that is truly the case, then maybe what is needed is a clarification of the terms of admittance.  It would be a good question to ask.  Hopefully, Lisa can help you. 

Expand  

You may be conflating federal 4473 wording with the TN HCP one, which includes:

".... has not been judicially committed to or hospitalized in a mental institution pursuant to title 33 ...."

No idea exactly how that is exactly interpreted currently, and not gonna try to pore through the definitions in title 33 for relevancy to the topic, but OP probably should.

- OS (not a lawyer)

 

Edited by Oh Shoot
  • Like 1
Posted
  On 12/18/2017 at 11:54 AM, Oh Shoot said:

You may be conflating federal 4473 wording with the TN HCP one, which includes:

".... has not been committed to or hospitalized in a mental institution...."

No idea exactly how that is exactly interpreted currently, except that generally in law an "or" means that part of a sentence stands alone.

- OS (not a lawyer)

 

Expand  

Good information. It sounds like TN law is tougher than Federal.  As you bolded above, the TN law states MENTAL institution.  JCanon, has stated MEDICAL institution in the original post, not mental. 

JCanon, that wording might also be good to bring up to Lisa, I bet she asks for it.

We are pulling for your husband, and we thank him for his service.

-I am NOT a lawyer either.

Posted

I could be wrong, but I don’t think this will be a legal battle over interpretation of the law or what the facility was called. I think it will be a common sense determination of the “suicidal” issue. I believe the board will have wide leeway on determining if that is still a factor.

This is exactly why many people won’t seek the mental health help they need. It puts a label on you that may impact you for the rest of your life. A PTSD diagnosis could end your right to have a gun to protect yourself and your family. I don’t know what the answer is.

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
  On 12/17/2017 at 6:33 PM, JCanan said:

Hey, I'm new here, so please be kind.

I have my CCW and my husband used to have one as well. He is a medically-retired Army veteran and his permit just expired on December 9th. He applied for a renewal but was denied bec he was sent to a medical institution 4 years ago for being suicidal and was honest about it on his application. What concerns me is, the reason he was suicial is bec the Army doc put him on Lyrica for chronic pain in his shoulders (he's had 3 surgeries) and one of the side effects is suicidal ideations. He told his physiologist that and they sent him straight to the hospital. He was immediately put on a different med for the pain and hasn't had that issue since. On the online application it gives you a place to explain certain answers, which he did, but they still denied him. I feel like they deciding party didn't even bother reading his explanation, but I can't prove it. My questions are 1) Does he ever have a chance of getting his permit back or is he screwed bec of a stupid medication?, 2) Does the medical hospitalization on his record ever "expire", so to speak? For example, after 5 years with no new issues, is it no longer considered a factor?, and 3) Since his permit renewal was denied, will that affect his background check if he tries to buy a new gun? He is a God-fearing man that worked hard to serve his country for 13 years (he only got out bec of injuries incurred while deployed), and has an outstanding military record as an enlisted soldier and then Army Captain. He is devistated. Is there anything we can do?

Expand  

So, here is the tough question...  Was your husband stay in the hospital an 'involuntary commitment'?

IANAL,

If your husband went to the hospital voluntarily, then he should have answered NO to Question #13A - see https://www.tn.gov/content/tn/safety/handgunmain/handgunfaqs.html#Q10

If your husband went to the hospital under an involuntary commitment, then he would be prevented for life from getting an HCP, and most likely be a 'prohibited person' under federal law from possessing any firearms for the rest of his life.  There seems to be some exception depending on the verbiage of the commitment, having to do with 'substantial likelihood of serious harm' and a 7 year sunset.

If it was a 'voluntary' visit, then I'd just fill the form out again, answer #13A as NO (see the link above), and if denied find a lawyer to appeal the denial.  

If it wasn't voluntary, I'd probably find a good lawyer and get a professional option on how this limits your husband's firearm rights.  

Let us know how it turns out please.

Edited by JayC
  • Like 1
Guest PAULSHOOT
Posted

Maybe your TN Legislatures (House Representative or Senator) would go to bat for you. 

I would try contacting one or more of them. 

They like appearing Patriotic to Veterans. 

Posted
  On 12/18/2017 at 7:22 PM, PAULSHOOT said:

Maybe your TN Legislatures (House Representative or Senator) would go to bat for you. 

I would try contacting one or more of them. 

They like appearing Patriotic to Veterans. 

Expand  

I doubt there is anything they could do, if he answer YES to #13A they're going to deny him period.  Either he answered #13A incorrectly, which means he should appeal the denial, and submit a corrected form...  or he answered it correctly and there is nothing anybody can do to get him a permit.

Posted
  On 12/18/2017 at 7:30 PM, JayC said:

I doubt there is anything they could do, if he answer YES to #13A they're going to deny him period.  Either he answered #13A incorrectly, which means he should appeal the denial, and submit a corrected form...  or he answered it correctly and there is nothing anybody can do to get him a permit.

Expand  

I had a friend who did just this. He appealed the denial by stating that he "misunderstood" the question. He changed his answer and got his permit renewed with no further problems.

Posted (edited)
  On 12/18/2017 at 3:17 PM, JayC said:

....

If your husband went to the hospital voluntarily, then he should have answered NO to Question #13A - see https://www.tn.gov/content/tn/safety/handgunmain/handgunfaqs.html#Q10

...

Expand  

The other possible prob is that Lyrica is on the federal controlled substance list, which TN uses as their definition also. And hospitalization for that has a ten three year reach, whether you voluntarily went in or not, and I suppose they could have gone with that.

edit: voluntary drug stay is three year, not ten

- OS

 

Edited by Oh Shoot
  • Wow 1
Posted
  On 12/19/2017 at 3:38 AM, Oh Shoot said:

The other possible prob is that Lyrica is on the federal controlled substance list, which TN uses as their definition also. And hospitalization for that has a ten year reach, whether you voluntarily went in or not, and I suppose they could have gone with that.

- OS

 

Expand  

Not unless there is something more to this story not disclosed in the original post.

The way I read her post, her husband was prescribed Lyrica by a doctor, and she didn't indicate that he was addicted or abusing it, only that he had an adverse side effect and stopped taking it.  Use of a controlled substance prescribed by a Doctor is not a factor that can cause you to be denied a permit, or even the purchase of a firearm. (With the exception of pot, but there are 4 people who are prescribed pot through a federal program who can legally own firearms).

So unless he is currently unlawfully using Lyrica, and/or is addicted to using Lyrica (or some other drug) then he wouldn't be denied a permit or have his rights to possess firearms revoked.

I really think his issue is #13A, he either marked yes when he shouldn't, or he was involuntarily committed and won't be able to get his permit back.

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
  On 12/19/2017 at 5:17 AM, JayC said:

Not unless there is something more to this story not disclosed in the original post.

The way I read her post, her husband was prescribed Lyrica by a doctor, and she didn't indicate that he was addicted or abusing it, only that he had an adverse side effect and stopped taking it.  Use of a controlled substance prescribed by a Doctor is not a factor that can cause you to be denied a permit, or even the purchase of a firearm. (With the exception of pot, but there are 4 people who are prescribed pot through a federal program who can legally own firearms).

So unless he is currently unlawfully using Lyrica, and/or is addicted to using Lyrica (or some other drug) then he wouldn't be denied a permit or have his rights to possess firearms revoked.

I really think his issue is #13A, he either marked yes when he shouldn't, or he was involuntarily committed and won't be able to get his permit back.

Expand  

Of course that is all correct.

And actually, even if they interpreted his explanation to trigger the voluntary admission for drug use, that actually has only a 3 year span, not 10 as I said in original post, so that shouldn't have been the zapper either.

But really, it's not like all the folks in this division of TNDOS have exactly appeal court justice level of legal wisdom or anything, so OP will need to get some direct communication with Lisa there to find out just what their stance is. And unfortunately it might ultimately require a hearing and a mouthpiece to get resolved in her hubbie's favor.

- OS

Edited by Oh Shoot
Posted
  On 12/19/2017 at 10:52 PM, Oh Shoot said:

Of course that is all correct.

And actually, even if they interpreted his explanation to trigger the voluntary admission for drug use, that actually has only a 3 year span, not 10 as I said in original post, so that shouldn't have been the zapper either.

But really, it's not like all the folks in this division of TNDOS have exactly appeal court justice level of legal wisdom or anything, so OP will need to get some direct communication with Lisa there to find out just what their stance is. And unfortunately it might ultimately require a hearing and a mouthpiece to get resolved in her hubbie's favor.

- OS

Expand  

I agree, but if the stay was voluntary, a simple call to Lisa, and filing an amended renewal form should be enough.  In theory the state would then have to prove you were ineligible...  but TDOS does some very stupid stuff that probably isn't legal on a regular basis.

  • Like 1
Posted
  On 12/18/2017 at 12:44 PM, DaveTN said:

I could be wrong, but I don’t think this will be a legal battle over interpretation of the law or what the facility was called. I think it will be a common sense determination of the “suicidal” issue. I believe the board will have wide leeway on determining if that is still a factor.

This is exactly why many people won’t seek the mental health help they need. It puts a label on you that may impact you for the rest of your life. A PTSD diagnosis could end your right to have a gun to protect yourself and your family. I don’t know what the answer is.

Expand  

I agree with this 100%. It sucks. 

Posted
  On 12/18/2017 at 3:17 PM, JayC said:

So, here is the tough question...  Was your husband stay in the hospital an 'involuntary commitment'?

IANAL,

If your husband went to the hospital voluntarily, then he should have answered NO to Question #13A - see https://www.tn.gov/content/tn/safety/handgunmain/handgunfaqs.html#Q10

If your husband went to the hospital under an involuntary commitment, then he would be prevented for life from getting an HCP, and most likely be a 'prohibited person' under federal law from possessing any firearms for the rest of his life.  There seems to be some exception depending on the verbiage of the commitment, having to do with 'substantial likelihood of serious harm' and a 7 year sunset.

If it was a 'voluntary' visit, then I'd just fill the form out again, answer #13A as NO (see the link above), and if denied find a lawyer to appeal the denial.  

If it wasn't voluntary, I'd probably find a good lawyer and get a professional option on how this limits your husband's firearm rights.  

Let us know how it turns out please.

Expand  

My husband's situation is weird as far as voluntary and involuntary admittance goes. He told the psychologist about being suicidal and was told that he could willingly go to the hospital, but if he didn't, they would forcibly take him (per Army protocol). My husband wanted help and knew it was a problem, so he willingly went and when his 2 weeks was up and he didn't feel better (he was slowly weaning off the meds in the facility), he asked if he could stay longer and they let him. 

Anyway, my husband called Lisa Knight two days ago but she wasn't in the office. I'm not sure who he ended up talking to, but the person told him to fill out the application again and mark no for question 13A instead of yes. My husband told him everything I shared with all of you, so he was aware of the situation as it stands. I guess we will see what happens and I'll keep you updated. 

Posted
  On 12/18/2017 at 7:22 PM, PAULSHOOT said:

Maybe your TN Legislatures (House Representative or Senator) would go to bat for you. 

I would try contacting one or more of them. 

They like appearing Patriotic to Veterans. 

Expand  

This is a great idea! As it stands, my husband loves contacting his local representatives, so that's the first thing he did. Haha :)

Posted
  On 12/19/2017 at 5:17 AM, JayC said:

Not unless there is something more to this story not disclosed in the original post.

The way I read her post, her husband was prescribed Lyrica by a doctor, and she didn't indicate that he was addicted or abusing it, only that he had an adverse side effect and stopped taking it.  Use of a controlled substance prescribed by a Doctor is not a factor that can cause you to be denied a permit, or even the purchase of a firearm. (With the exception of pot, but there are 4 people who are prescribed pot through a federal program who can legally own firearms).

So unless he is currently unlawfully using Lyrica, and/or is addicted to using Lyrica (or some other drug) then he wouldn't be denied a permit or have his rights to possess firearms revoked.

I really think his issue is #13A, he either marked yes when he shouldn't, or he was involuntarily committed and won't be able to get his permit back.

Expand  

He absolutely was not misusing Lyrica. That stuff is horrible and he hated every minute on it. He didn't want to take it to begin with but you have to follow protocol in the military in order to be deemed compliant, so he took it as directed. When he told him psychologist about the way he was feeling on it they asked him to check himself into the hospital, which he willingly did. They did mention that if he didn't, they would forcibly take him, but it never got to that, as he hated how he felt and wanted to get better. 

Posted
  On 12/24/2017 at 2:13 AM, JCanan said:

My husband's situation is weird as far as voluntary and involuntary admittance goes. He told the psychologist about being suicidal and was told that he could willingly go to the hospital, but if he didn't, they would forcibly take him (per Army protocol). My husband wanted help and knew it was a problem, so he willingly went and when his 2 weeks was up and he didn't feel better (he was slowly weaning off the meds in the facility), he asked if he could stay longer and they let him. 

Anyway, my husband called Lisa Knight two days ago but she wasn't in the office. I'm not sure who he ended up talking to, but the person told him to fill out the application again and mark no for question 13A instead of yes. My husband told him everything I shared with all of you, so he was aware of the situation as it stands. I guess we will see what happens and I'll keep you updated. 

Expand  

That sounds like a voluntary admittance, so he should be good to go, let us know what happens please.  These forms are pretty complicated, but as a general rule if you'd marking YES to one of those questions it's going to cause you to be denied.

  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

TRADING POST NOTICE

Before engaging in any transaction of goods or services on TGO, all parties involved must know and follow the local, state and Federal laws regarding those transactions.

TGO makes no claims, guarantees or assurances regarding any such transactions.

THE FINE PRINT

Tennessee Gun Owners (TNGunOwners.com) is the premier Community and Discussion Forum for gun owners, firearm enthusiasts, sportsmen and Second Amendment proponents in the state of Tennessee and surrounding region.

TNGunOwners.com (TGO) is a presentation of Enthusiast Productions. The TGO state flag logo and the TGO tri-hole "icon" logo are trademarks of Tennessee Gun Owners. The TGO logos and all content presented on this site may not be reproduced in any form without express written permission. The opinions expressed on TGO are those of their authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the site's owners or staff.

TNGunOwners.com (TGO) is not a lobbying organization and has no affiliation with any lobbying organizations.  Beware of scammers using the Tennessee Gun Owners name, purporting to be Pro-2A lobbying organizations!

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to the following.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Guidelines
 
We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.