Mugster is spot on about the game taste. Leaving blood in your venison will taint the taste. I butcher my own deer and after skinning I place the quarters in a cooler of ice. I keep the meat in the cooler for up to a week. I drain the bloody water off 3 times a day and add ice as required to keep the meat covered. This has always yielded good tasting meat for me. I used this same method in Florida on wild pigs for years and even the old nasty boars came out good.
Here is my favorite venison recipe:
For backstrap on the grill, this is the best venison I have put in my mouth.
Sweet Bacon-Wrapped Venison Tenderloin Recipe : Recipezaar
Ingredients
2 lbs venison tenderloins (a single deer loin or Moose or Elk or Pork or Beef)
1/2 lb bacon
3 cups brown sugar
2 cups soy sauce
1/4 cup white sugar (Optional for added Sweetness)
Directions
Mix brown Sugar and Soy sauce together in a bowl. They should combine nicely into a soupy soy liquid.
Put Deer Loin in a cooking tray and pour Brown Sugar/Soy Sauce mixture over loin. Roll tenderloin over in mixture, completely covering it.
Let meat marinate in mixture at least 3 hours or overnight in fridge. It's best to marinate for 8 hours if you have the time. Also GREAT to use a Food Saver or other Vacuum device to Vacuum pack/seal the meat with Marinade. With this method, you can achieve Overnight-level marinade in just a couple hours!
Remove loin from tray, and place on a slotted bake sheet with a drip pan or aluminum foil below to catch dripping. Don't throw away marinade.
Wrap a piece of bacon around the very end of the tenderloin, securing the bacon strip with a toothpick.
Repeat this process until the entire loin is wrapped in ten or so bacon "loops." The tenderloin should look like an arm with a bunch of wrist watches on it, the watches being the bacon strips.
Drizzle remaining marinade over deer loin. You can continue to baste the loin with the marinade throughout the cooking process with either a brush or a turkey baster.
Place on center rack in oven and bake at 350°F for 30-40 minutes. OR GRILL! Just watch the flare ups!
OPTIONAL - with about 10 minutes of cooking time left, you can lightly dust the top of the loin with white sugar. This creates a sweet crust on top of the bacon. Might be too sweet for some. Try doing it on just HALF of the loin to see if you like it!
1Remove from oven and place on cutting board. Using a knife, cut the loin between each strip of bacon so that you have many pieces of meat, each with their own toothpick.
You can eat these pieces directly from the toothpick or remove the toothpick and eat like steak. You can thank me later.