Lincoln, JFK, J. Edgar Hoover, Nixon, Reagan, Clinton, etc.
I in no way said it was acceptable or right. I simply make the point that this has been going on behind the scenes for a long time going back to even the Civil War technology aside and that now it is finally defined and addressable.
When did this become a "real" issue? It certainly wasn't a mainstream conversation before Bush 2. So my point is not that Bush was right to do it, but rather by bringing it to the public eye in the way of the Patriot Act, it made what had been done in secret tangible and visible. With the curtain removed it has allowed for Americans to have discourse and an actionable subject to deal with. whether this was intentional by Bush 2 or not is irrelevant. These conversation were considered tinfoil topics as recently as the Clinton administration.
Our freedoms are being eroded away but not by the Patriot Act. t is being done with other much less obvious methods like socialism, taxes, education, political correctness, etc.